Skip to content

McWilliams Moving & Storage Ltd

Mover in Peterborough, Ontario

Google rating

4.4

Ratings counted

139

Are 1 or 2 star

12.9%Above typical

The rating breakdown

18 of the 139 ratings in Google’s published star breakdown for McWilliams Moving & Storage Ltd are one or two star.

Against other listings in Peterborough

This company12.9%
Typical listing in Peterborough6.2%

6.7 percentage points higher than the middle of the 16 listings in Peterborough we can publish a rate for.

Google’s published star breakdown

Distribution of star ratings as published by Google
RatingDistributionCountShare
5 star
11482.0%
4 star
53.6%
3 star
21.4%
2 star
32.2%
1 star
1510.8%

Counts as published by Google in its star breakdown, not the reviews we have read. Google also publishes a review count, which does not always match this total. Each row is rounded on its own, so the shares need not add to exactly 100%.

Against every mover we can rate
0–5%
7,614
5–10%
2,324
10–20%
1,521
20%+
538

The marker is McWilliams Moving & Storage Ltd at 12.9%. The typical mover among the 11,997 we can publish a rate for sits at 3.2%.

Every company with at least 20 ratings in Google’s published star breakdown. Rates come from those breakdowns, not from the reviews we have read.

What the complaints say

Moving goes wrong in a small number of specific ways. These are the ones reviewers describe in the low-star reviews we have read for McWilliams Moving & Storage Ltd, counted by matching the words they used.

  • Damage to belongings7 · 44%
  • Crew conduct5 · 31%
  • Price rose after the quote4 · 25%
  • Items missing or never delivered3 · 19%
  • Stopped responding1 · 6%

Counted across the 16 one and two star reviews we have read for McWilliams Moving & Storage Ltd. A review can describe more than one problem, so these do not add to 100%. Each share is rounded on its own.

In their own words

1-star Google reviewMichael M.a year ago
I used McWilliams for my move more than a year ago after they came highly recommended. Crew was yelling and fighting with each other all day, and rushed the job because of this. Multiple dropped/broken boxes, and dings in the walls and floor of my old place causing damage. Last item of the day was a big steel cabinet that the crew decided to tip towards the only other item in the room, a chandelier/light fixture.
1-star Google reviewPeter M.8 years ago
I am not a demanding person who needs that much to keep me happy but this was the stand-out single worst customer service I have experienced on my 41 years on this fair planet: * This company damaged our irreplaceable century home doorway on the way out, in front of our eyes (when I took pictures, which is the only reason they sent us a claims cheque, but for a mere $150 after originally suggesting to agree to what I thought was a modest $300 over the phone) * we never got a firm answer on a date when our stuff…
1-star Google reviewAllie K.5 years ago
TLDR: Non-existent customer service, terrible communication, overcharging and underquoting, unaware of their own policies. Terrible, would NOT recommend. We had been recommended McWilliams through the University of Waterloo, as my partner and I are both alumni and I am a current graduate students. We also had a friend who is a UW Faculty Member use McWilliams a few months prior and they had a great experience. We requested an estimate and Paul G.
2-star Google reviewNick C.a year ago
I have to say I'm a bit disappointed with McWilliams. We had Vycki come into our home and do an estimate...Before we moved we sold alot of our contents to make the move easier. Moving day went quick we started with 3 guys with a large truck. Half way through the move 3 other guys showed up. Unloading at our new place was a bit different, again started with 3 guys, then another 3 showed up.
1-star Google reviewRemo B.9 years ago
Worst moving company ever. If I could give them 0 starts I would! I moved my households outside Canada and they charge me 3720 lb more than the actual weight! They cheat on the weight, they do their own weight and they throw you a random number which is usually 3-4000 lb more than the actual weight. This Company is a SCAM.
1-star Google reviewCarol M.3 years ago
I have moved 3 times with McWilliams and my last experience was horrible. I paid for the replacement value insurance. There were a number of damaged items, so I filed a claim. They took months to reply and after numerous calls and emails, they finally sent a cheque for a couple of items. (I could not cash the cheque, because it referenced full and final payment) They then picked up a number of pieces that they were going to repair (apparently they have that option).
Reply from the business

Carol, we apologize for your recent experience. Our team has reached out to you several times to schedule the return of your repaired items but you have not been available to accept them. We pride ourselves on our customer service and the top quality standards we provide on each move.

1-star Google reviewMarg D.11 years ago
Very disappointed in this company. Our moving weight was underestimated by 3500 pounds and we were charged $2100.00 more than originally quoted. When we complained about the overcharge and stated that we went to McWilliams because they were half the price of the other movers, the Branch Manager said, we should have known something was wrong, if the other movers were higher. We are not professional movers and trusted that the man estimating our move knew what he was doing.
1-star Google reviewTanya B.10 months ago
We used McWilliams to move from the South. Driver showed up demanding we meet with him at a time we were meeting already with someone taking care of our property. Driver threatened to leave our belongings. Rest of the move went mostly fine except for a smashed china cabinet. Then this Spring my business was moving and an employee Vickie Meeks came in telling me she worked for McWilliams, could move us across the street etc. We didn't really need help.
Reply from the business

Hi Tanya, We’re sorry to hear that your moving experience with us was not completely positive. Has your China cabinet claim been resolved? If not, please email [email removed] so that we can ensure any damage caused during a move can be rectified.

What satisfied customers point to

The same method, applied to the four and five star reviews. Most movers are praised for the same handful of things, so what is missing here is often as telling as what is present.

  • Professional and courteous58 · 61%
  • Worked hard and fast29 · 31%
  • Turned up when they said21 · 22%
  • Careful with belongings17 · 18%
  • Kept in touch7 · 7%
  • Price matched the quote2 · 2%

Counted across the 95 four and five star reviews we have read for McWilliams Moving & Storage Ltd. A review can mention more than one thing.

In their own words

5-star Google reviewTerry H.3 years ago
We just used McWilliams Moving. All of the crew was professional, hardworking, sought our input and were extremely careful. They worked hard and asked where items were supposed to go. Our household items were picked up in Brighton, Ontario and delivered two days later to Leamington, Ontario. Thanks Chad and Jamie and the rest of the crew! Our ping pong table did not fit in the basement so we disassembled it but they held the pieces so nothing broke and could be taken down to the basement and reassembled.
Reply from the business

Thank you Terry for this wonderful review and kind words. We appreciate your business and taking the time to share your experience. We strive for this kind of feedback with each and every customer. We hope you have settled into your new home!

5-star Google reviewBrad S.a year ago
My wife and I recently moved from Toronto to a smaller town. We were concerned about the choice of moving company - everyone has a horror story. McWilliams put all those stories to bed. They arrived on time. They were courteous. They asked our names so that they could be in constant communication with us - and they were. They seemed genuinely interested in what we were doing. They kept on working steadily and finished on time. The plan had them delivering our goods the next day starting at 8 am.
Reply from the business

Thank you Brad for this wonderful review! McWilliams strives to go above and beyond for our customers. Thank you for choosing McWilliams. We hope you are settled into your new home.

5-star Google reviewTony W.a year ago
McWilliams Moving and Storage in Peterborough, Ontario is a great company with great attention to detail. We utilized their services for a move from Utah, USA to Trent Hills, Ontario -Canada. The move was conducted flawlessly from load-out in Utah to delivery in Ontario. Amanda provided great detailed information in getting the move booked and helping with all of the related Customs and Border paperwork. Her knowledge and patience was extremely valuable.
Reply from the business

Thank you Tony for taking the time to leave such a detailed and genuine review of your personal experience with McWilliams! Feedback like this motivates our team to continue delivering top notch service and expertise.

5-star Google reviewwanda A.8 years ago
We decided on McWilliams Moving to move our worldly belongings from Ontario to Winnipeg. Although, we had met with two other companies that had similar quotes we were given a glowing reference from a complete stranger at the moving supply store. She told us that Peter at McWilliams was a pleasure to deal with and had moved her family to Campbell River, BC with great results. She was correct, Peter and his staff Bonnie and Cheryl handled our questions and took care of our moving needs like we were family!

What Google’s own summary highlights

Google surfaces topics it finds across a business’s reviews. They skew positive across every mover we hold, so treat them as a summary of what this company is praised for rather than a balanced picture.

  • courteous staff17
  • professional crew10
  • estimate7
  • careful movers5
  • fun driver3
  • flawless move2
  • prompt responses2
  • quote process2
  • accurate quote2
  • long-distance moving2

What the company says about itself

Taken from McWilliams Moving & Storage Ltd’s own website. These are statements the business makes, not things we have verified — we have no way to check them, and neither claim nor absence should be read as a finding.

  • States how long it has tradedsays on their website
    Show the text this came from

    “Y WE'RE YOUR TRUSTED MOVING EXPERTS For over 60 years, McWilliams Moving & Storage has ca”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.

Where else this company appears

Pages elsewhere that name this business. Matched on name and location, so a listing here is a lead worth checking rather than a confirmed identity.

  • chamberofcommerce.comdirectory
  • birdeye.comreviews
  • profilecanada.comdirectory

Before you hire McWilliams Moving & Storage Ltd

Whatever this company’s numbers say, the same handful of things go wrong on a move. These guides are how to keep your side of it tight.

All moving guides →

Other listings in Peterborough

BusinessGoogle rating
My Storage PeterboroughSelf-storage facility · Peterborough, Ontario4.6198
EMS MoversMover · Peterborough, Ontario4.9173
Access Storage - Peterborough EastSelf-storage facility · Peterborough, Ontario4.8161
Happy Haulers Junk & MovingWaste management service · Peterborough, Ontario5.0141
Seniors Relocation ServicesMoving and storage service · Peterborough, Ontario5.094
GO Moving & ServicesMover · Peterborough, Ontario4.688

See all 21 listings in Peterborough →