Skip to content

Herlihy Moving & Storage

Moving and storage service in Springfield, Ohio

Its address is in Grove City, Ohio. It appears here because Google returns it for Springfield.

Google rating

4.7

Ratings counted

122

Are 1 or 2 star

6.6%Above typical

The rating breakdown

8 of the 122 ratings in Google’s published star breakdown for Herlihy Moving & Storage are one or two star.

Against other listings in Springfield

This company6.6%
Typical listing in Springfield3.1%

3.4 percentage points higher than the middle of the 11 listings in Springfield we can publish a rate for.

Google’s published star breakdown

Distribution of star ratings as published by Google
RatingDistributionCountShare
5 star
10787.7%
4 star
43.3%
3 star
32.5%
2 star
00%
1 star
86.6%

Counts as published by Google in its star breakdown, not the reviews we have read. Google also publishes a review count, which does not always match this total. Each row is rounded on its own, so the shares need not add to exactly 100%.

Against every mover we can rate
0–5%
7,614
5–10%
2,324
10–20%
1,521
20%+
538

The marker is Herlihy Moving & Storage at 6.6%. The typical mover among the 11,997 we can publish a rate for sits at 3.2%.

Every company with at least 20 ratings in Google’s published star breakdown. Rates come from those breakdowns, not from the reviews we have read.

What the complaints say

Moving goes wrong in a small number of specific ways. These are the ones reviewers describe in the low-star reviews we have read for Herlihy Moving & Storage, counted by matching the words they used.

  • Damage to belongings3 · 50%
  • Price rose after the quote1 · 17%
  • Items missing or never delivered1 · 17%
  • Late, delayed or a no-show1 · 17%

Counted across the 6 one and two star reviews we have read for Herlihy Moving & Storage. A review can describe more than one problem, so these do not add to 100%. Each share is rounded on its own.

In their own words

1-star Google reviewPamela D.7 years ago
Chaotic, ill prepared and poor execution Herlihy movers showed up with 3 smallish men to move a 3,800 sq ft house. The men worked hard but this job was too big for the number of people they sent. Then the crew told us they were finished and left. Day 2, I returned to my home and every room still had furniture and boxes in it and things scattered around. The house was sold and this was scheduled as a one day move. I had to call the owner and send photos to prove the mess.
Reply from the business

Dear Mrs. Dixon. Thank you for sharing your perceptions concerning your recent move. We regret that miscommunication over the size of your move resulted in a frustrating process. Herlihy Mayflower strives for 100% customer satisfaction, and we regret that you remain unsatisfied.

1-star Google reviewAnita C.5 years ago
Our experience with Herlihy was the worst move I have ever had. It costs a lot to move, so this review is a long one, but worth reading to avoid investing a huge amount of money for you and all your stuff to be treated badly. The initial estimation process for our long-distance move was great. Once we were assigned a moving coordinator, things went south really fast. Basically, she did nothing for us. Email was not answered, we had to call her every time for any updates.
Reply from the business

I’m sorry our business did not meet your expectations, and we appreciate you sharing your feedback.

1-star Google reviewClara K.4 years ago
Herlihy came highly recommended though we, unfortunately, had a terrible experience. The movers were inexperienced, did not work together to move things (resulting in nearly every item being damaged), and disappeared from the job for over two hours without warning. When we called corporate to see what was going on, we were told the movers did not secure the ramp that is used to load the truck and it flew off on the highway.
Reply from the business

We're sorry to hear you were less than satisfied with your move. Doing business with honesty and integrity is extremely important to us. Please continue working with our team to get this resolved.

1-star Google reviewCindy W.4 years ago
We needed to move out of our rental house and put our items in temporary storage before moving into our new home. We worked with Brandon ahead of time to plan the process. The moving team that unpacked and moved our belongings into our new home were attentive, helpful, and professional, but even they seemed shocked at the complete mess that the team that came to pack our belongings did. Boxes that had fragile written on them were crushed. We couldn't reassemble our shelves because they lost entire corner sections.
Reply from the business

Cindy, we're sorry to hear you have some concerns about your move and would like to investigate further. However, we're unable to identify you based on your review. At your convenience, please call Mayflower Customer Care at [phone removed].

1-star Google reviewJulia A.6 years ago
Having been transferred all over the U.S. this is the shortest distance and worst move we have ever made. So many broken dishes, furniture chipped, and legs broken off of an antique buffet and table, family heirlooms broken just the worst!! The guys who loaded us were nice but seemed tired and lacked experience. I would never recommend this company!! They put beds together with wrong parts from other beds, and we are still looking for hardware to put things back together.
Reply from the business

Dear Julia. Thanks for sharing your feedback. We're sorry your experience didn't match your expectations. We sent a claims form for covered damages and have made several attempts to reach you via phone. Please give us a call at [phone removed]. We would love to work with you to make things right.

1-star Google reviewCharlie R.3 years ago
If possible I'd give them zero stars. Worst moving experience ever. Do yourself a favor and hire any one other than Herlihy Moving and storage.
Reply from the business

Your input is of great value to us. If you'd like to talk about your experience, please call Mayflower Customer Care at [phone removed]. Thank you for your time.

What satisfied customers point to

The same method, applied to the four and five star reviews. Most movers are praised for the same handful of things, so what is missing here is often as telling as what is present.

  • Professional and courteous52 · 60%
  • Worked hard and fast33 · 38%
  • Careful with belongings17 · 20%
  • Turned up when they said14 · 16%
  • Kept in touch6 · 7%
  • Price matched the quote2 · 2%

Counted across the 87 four and five star reviews we have read for Herlihy Moving & Storage. A review can mention more than one thing.

In their own words

5-star Google reviewProlifemama9 years ago
I learned of Herlihy's Moving & Storage via their commercials on AM820 St. Gabriel Catholic Radio. They are a first-class professional moving company with proficient teams and very competitive pricing. The team consisted of Dorrian, Mike and John – true gentlemen and skilled movers all – and arrived on time, ready to begin loading. They are highly proficient in logistics, and thoroughly answered all questions.
Reply from the business

Thank you so much for taking the time to describe your experience! We appreciate your kind words and referrals.

5-star Google reviewMelody S.5 years ago
The Herlihy staff was responsive and helpful in estimating and planning my move from the beginning. The movers were on time, friendly, professional and very accommodating. My new home has difficult access and, when they arrived and couldn't get the loaded van up the driveway to the house, without a word of complaint, they carried everything up two fights of stairs and several deck levels! And not a thing was broken, or damaged in any way. I couldn't have asked for better service!
Reply from the business

Melody, Thank you so much for your review and recommendation. We’re glad to hear the crew took good care of you. We’ll make sure to share your feedback with the team. Best wishes to you as you settle into your new home!

5-star Google reviewSusie B.12 years ago
Very pleasant. Roy made the initial visit for the estimate very easy and was very informative on the first visit. He was the only carrier representative that came on time on the first date we scheduled. For various reasons, all the other companies either never called or called to reschedule at least once. Roy made a follow-up visit to bring some free used packing materials that really came in handy during the packing process which we chose to do ourselves.
Reply from the business

Thank you!

5-star Google reviewEmily S.10 years ago
We had a great time moving with Herlihy. They moved us on a hot Saturday morning in June, and their men were polite, personable and speedy. So speedy, in fact, that we ended up paying $200 less than our quote! I especially liked how willing the men were to help out. We were not completely prepared when they arrive (they showed up at 8:35 within a window of 8:30-9:30), and the men took care of a few final things: rolling up our rug, taking the leaf out of our table.
Reply from the business

Thank you!!!

What Google’s own summary highlights

Google surfaces topics it finds across a business’s reviews. They skew positive across every mover we hold, so treat them as a summary of what this company is praised for rather than a balanced picture.

  • professional crew15
  • cost10
  • friendly movers7
  • estimate5
  • easy process3
  • responsive staff2
  • mattress move2
  • cost savings2
  • rental2
  • honest moving company2

What the company says about itself

Taken from Herlihy Moving & Storage’s own website. These are statements the business makes, not things we have verified — we have no way to check them, and neither claim nor absence should be read as a finding.

  • Advertises free estimatessays on their website
    Show the text this came from

    “…and Chillicothe. Self Storage QUOTE Free Quote Request Name (Required) Email (Required”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.

  • Describes itself as family ownedsays on their website
    Show the text this came from

    “Columbus, OH & Surrounding Area Family-owned Herlihy Mayflower Moving & Storage”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.

  • States a founding yearsays on their website
    Show the text this came from

    “…provided local and long distance moving since 1920, and have moved thousands of Ohio famil”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.

  • Mentions the Better Business Bureausays on their website
    Show the text this came from

    “…satisfied customers. We also have an A+ Rating with the Better Business Bureau of Cent”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.

Before you hire Herlihy Moving & Storage

Whatever this company’s numbers say, the same handful of things go wrong on a move. These guides are how to keep your side of it tight.

All moving guides →

Other listings in Springfield

BusinessGoogle rating
Werner Enterprises IncTrucking company · Springfield, Ohio4.2392
Stop-N-Go Storage of SpringfieldSelf-storage facility · Springfield, Ohio4.8193
Sebastian Moving SW OhioMover · Springfield, Ohio · based in Sabina4.9170
Greg's HaulingWaste management service · Springfield, Ohio5.0159
Springfield Storage DepotSelf-storage facility · Springfield, Ohio4.584
Top Quality Movers LLCMoving and storage service · Springfield, Ohio4.975

See all 11 listings in Springfield →