Skip to content

StorageMart

Self-storage facility at 10415 Allisonville Rd in Fishers, Indiana

Google rating

4.9

Ratings counted

464

Are 1 or 2 star

2.6%Around typical

Google carries another listing under this name in Fishers. They may be separate branches or duplicate entries for the same business — we cannot tell which, so we publish both: the other listing.

The rating breakdown

12 of the 464 ratings in Google’s published star breakdown for StorageMart are one or two star.

Against other listings in Fishers

This company2.6%
Typical listing in Fishers7.4%

4.8 percentage points lower than the middle of the 7 listings in Fishers we can publish a rate for.

Google’s published star breakdown

Distribution of star ratings as published by Google
RatingDistributionCountShare
5 star
43293.1%
4 star
173.7%
3 star
30.6%
2 star
51.1%
1 star
71.5%

Counts as published by Google in its star breakdown, not the reviews we have read. Google also publishes a review count, which does not always match this total. Each row is rounded on its own, so the shares need not add to exactly 100%.

Against every mover we can rate
0–5%
7,614
5–10%
2,324
10–20%
1,521
20%+
538

The marker is StorageMart at 2.6%. The typical mover among the 11,997 we can publish a rate for sits at 3.2%.

Every company with at least 20 ratings in Google’s published star breakdown. Rates come from those breakdowns, not from the reviews we have read.

What the complaints say

Moving goes wrong in a small number of specific ways. These are the ones reviewers describe in the low-star reviews we have read for StorageMart, counted by matching the words they used.

  • Crew conduct3 · 27%

Counted across the 11 one and two star reviews we have read for StorageMart. A review can describe more than one problem, so these do not add to 100%. Each share is rounded on its own.

In their own words

1-star Google reviewDiana S.a year ago
Google Review Draft: I recently had a very disappointing and unprofessional experience with Ray, the regional manager, at this location. I was sitting in my car at 4:57 PM I was on a very important phone call when Ray approached my vehicle and rudely informed me they were “getting ready to close.” He said that if I wanted their help, I needed to come in right now. His tone was harsh and unwelcoming, as if I was an inconvenience. When I entered the office, Ray continued to be short and dismissive with me.
Reply from the business

Thank you for your feedback, Diana. We're sorry to hear your experience wasn't up to our usual standards. Your satisfaction is important to us, and we'd appreciate the chance to make it right.

1-star Google reviewCarmen M.4 years ago
I strongly recommend anyone considering storage do not rent from Storage Mart. I have items stored here for 4 years now and in that time this property has been sold 2 times. Each time a new owner comes in that results in a significant increase in your monthly rate of which the onsite management team can not do anything about. My monthly rate has more than doubled from when I first moved item in until now.
Reply from the business

Thank you for your review.

2-star Google reviewJohn W.a year ago
The only reason this is not a 1 star review is because of how wonderful Amanda is. I have had a unit in the climate control area for a few years with no incident until now. I have been keeping my grandfathers old furniture in there since his passing this January. I went into my unit last week for the first time in a month to discover mold on all the furniture! I immediately went to the front desk and Amanda was fantastic in helping me with everything I needed.
Reply from the business

John, We're sorry to hear about your experience at our facility. Providing the best service possible is our top priority, and we'd appreciate the chance to discuss this further. Please don't hesitate to reach out to us directly at [email removed] at your convenience.

1-star Google reviewLori D.4 years ago
I would not recommend this place to anyone. I have had things stored there for several years and it has changed hands twice. The price just continues to increase. This time the experience was awful. I did not receive info that there was a change. I didn’t realize they stopped charging my credit card. They said they emailed a letter but went to spam probably. Why didn’t they send a letter in the mail. Instead they send a letter saying they are auctioning my things in April. I immediately went in to pay.
Reply from the business

We are sorry to hear about this and will be discussing the issue with the appropriate parties. Thank you for the review, Lori.

1-star Google reviewMike I.Edited a year ago
Nice selection, competitive price, great service made this an easy decision. Then 2 months later, the doubled the rent. They wait till you move all your stuff over and get it settled, then they raise the price after the manager promised they wouldn’t. When I confronted the manager, they said they had no control over pricing. Well why did they say there would be no price increases. The previous storage facility did that to me also. Buyer beware.
Reply from the business

Thank you for the 5 star review, Mike! We're glad that renting at our Allisonville storage facility was quick and easy!

2-star Google reviewGregory S.Edited 2 years ago
The manager at the place is not friendly he is rude the place is locked up tighter than fort Knox the bathrooms are locked up and when he is not here you can't use the bathrooms or anything so what's one supposed to do also the prices go up every 6 months hate to leave this place cuz it's safe and climate control. At the manager was more friendlier it might make a difference and I might stay but he's the reason I'm leaving and the price as well
Reply from the business

Hi Gregory, thank you for the high star rating! If you ever need anything else from us, please feel free to give us a call or stop by. Have an awesome day!

2-star Google reviewAngel D.3 years ago
I like the storage but the manager and his staff set me up supposedly on auto pay now I have a fee for none payment and they are not taking responsibility for not doing what they said they would do. Saying sorry, is not acceptable and I’m moving out after one month. If I don’t trust a company to give me accurate information and to make it right if they do mess up I will not continue business with them.
Reply from the business

Thank you for your review.

2-star Google reviewKaine S.3 years ago
B DD dd...vd .dcvdvcd.fdmddmdmd.v d.vaf.d dddvc Nvcnfdvmfvddvd.vdmdvb.v. . . V . V .av . ..... . . V.nd .a.cv.d .vd.v..f.f... DD d. .d.ff .ddddvddv vs b..... .. D.f. f. V.ddf.... .n.d vd .v..v..d bd DD D.d.fdf CD dvn .bv . M . CNN s..v do ddddvdmddfdv dv v ddddvddv d Dd cdddd V.... .n . D .vf.fd....d.vd.. .fd. DD ddddd DD dddd DVD ddbdd..d...da. B..f. ..nbf
Reply from the business

Thank you for your review.

What satisfied customers point to

The same method, applied to the four and five star reviews. Most movers are praised for the same handful of things, so what is missing here is often as telling as what is present.

  • Professional and courteous98 · 26%
  • Worked hard and fast35 · 9%
  • Turned up when they said6 · 2%
  • Kept in touch2 · <1%
  • Careful with belongings1 · <1%
  • Price matched the quote1 · <1%

Counted across the 370 four and five star reviews we have read for StorageMart. A review can mention more than one thing.

In their own words

5-star Google reviewDorothea L.Edited a year ago
04/08/2025 This is a new addition to my previous review. I am still a customer of StorageMart on Allisonville Rd. During my visits I always appreciate the security, easy access, and cleanliness. When I visit I sometimes interact with staff. Amanda, who recently assisted me, was professional and so helpful. She answered several questions to my satisfaction. With Amanda’s help, my visits and transactions are easy and quick. Amanda also promptly replies to my phone calls and has a pleasant voice.
Reply from the business

We're glad that you’re satisfied with your Allisonville Road storage facility, Dorothea! Thanks for letting us know.

5-star Google reviewMerrik M.7 years ago
10/10 - Highly recommend for anyone looking for storage space in the Fishers area. Great price and the onsite staff is very friendly and accommodating. The units are in wonderful condition and very clean.
Reply from the business

Hi A Google User, we are very happy to have provided you with such a positive experience!

5-star Google reviewAbby S.a year ago
We’ve had a great experience with Storage Mart. Amanda was excellent in helping us get our unit and explaining everything we needed to know. The property is clean and well protected. Thanks again!
Reply from the business

Hi Abby, Thank you for sharing the wonderful experience you had with the team at our 10415 Allisonville Rd location! We're thrilled to hear that they provided you with excellent customer service. Your kind words mean a lot to us, and we're grateful to have such dedicated staff on our team.

5-star Google reviewD. B.6 years ago
Rented a 10 x 10 for extra household goods. Pricing is competitive. Units clean and accessible. Staff is courteous and responsive. I was very happy with the experience.
Reply from the business

D. Brown, thank you for your kind review; we are happy to pass along your comments to the team here at Storage Sense!

What Google’s own summary highlights

Google surfaces topics it finds across a business’s reviews. They skew positive across every mover we hold, so treat them as a summary of what this company is praised for rather than a balanced picture.

  • helpful manager33
  • clean units10
  • temperature control8
  • rental process6
  • easy setup4
  • easy checkout4
  • welcoming atmosphere3
  • secure access2
  • quick and easy2
  • value for money2

What the company says about itself

Taken from StorageMart’s own website. These are statements the business makes, not things we have verified — we have no way to check them, and neither claim nor absence should be read as a finding.

  • States a founding yearsays on their website
    Show the text this came from

    “…dedicated to the self storage industry since 1987. Since the founding of StorageMart in 1”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.

  • Describes itself as family ownedsays on their website
    Show the text this came from

    “We have grown to become the largest family-owned and privately operated self storage com”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.

  • Mentions the Better Business Bureausays on their website
    Show the text this came from

    “…of the Year, the Torch Award from the Better Business Bureau, and the CEO Award for 2020 and 2021 fr”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.

  • Advertises 24/7 availabilitysays on their website
    Show the text this came from

    “…access into our facility. Paired with 24/7 video surveillance, you can rest assure”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.

  • Says it is licensedsays on their website
    Show the text this came from

    “…by TKG III Fishers, LLC, which is licensed to use the StorageMart logo by StorageM”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.

Where else this company appears

Pages elsewhere that name this business. Matched on name and location, so a listing here is a lead worth checking rather than a confirmed identity.

  • yellowpages.comdirectory
  • yelp.comreviews

Before you hire StorageMart

Whatever this company’s numbers say, the same handful of things go wrong on a move. These guides are how to keep your side of it tight.

All moving guides →

Other listings in Fishers

BusinessGoogle rating
Wheaton World Wide MovingMover · Fishers, Indiana · based in Indianapolis4.6991
StorageMartSelf-storage facility · Fishers, Indiana4.9275
Life TransitionsMover · Fishers, Indiana5.0118
Triple Berry MovingMoving and storage service · Fishers, Indiana4.797
Melby's MoversMover · Fishers, Indiana4.727
J Lopez MovingMover · Fishers, Indiana4.024

See all 8 listings in Fishers →