Skip to content

Lighthouse Storage

Self-storage facility in Evansville, Indiana

Google rating

4.7

Ratings counted

314

Are 1 or 2 star

5.4%Around typical

The rating breakdown

17 of the 314 ratings in Google’s published star breakdown for Lighthouse Storage are one or two star.

Against other listings in Evansville

This company5.4%
Typical listing in Evansville6.0%

About the same as the middle of the 14 listings in Evansville we can publish a rate for.

Google’s published star breakdown

Distribution of star ratings as published by Google
RatingDistributionCountShare
5 star
26684.7%
4 star
299.2%
3 star
20.6%
2 star
00%
1 star
175.4%

Counts as published by Google in its star breakdown, not the reviews we have read. Google also publishes a review count, which does not always match this total. Each row is rounded on its own, so the shares need not add to exactly 100%.

Against every mover we can rate
0–5%
7,048
5–10%
1,993
10–20%
1,265
20%+
454

The marker is Lighthouse Storage at 5.4%. The typical mover among the 10,760 we can publish a rate for sits at 3.0%.

Every company with at least 20 ratings in Google’s published star breakdown. Rates come from those breakdowns, not from the reviews we have read.

What the complaints say

Moving goes wrong in a small number of specific ways. These are the ones reviewers describe in the low-star reviews we have read for Lighthouse Storage, counted by matching the words they used.

  • Damage to belongings4 · 22%
  • Items missing or never delivered2 · 11%
  • Price rose after the quote1 · 6%
  • Claim or refund went nowhere1 · 6%
  • Crew conduct1 · 6%

Counted across the 18 one and two star reviews we have read for Lighthouse Storage. A review can describe more than one problem, so these do not add to 100%. Each share is rounded on its own.

In their own words

1-star Google reviewMichael M.5 years ago
If you have an RV or any other kind of vehicle you are thinking of storing here, please STOP! They only got one star because I had too give something. Our Class C had the catalytic converter stolen as well as a side mirror and some other damage. I took pictures of the fence area where anybody could easily get in and there are no cameras in the parking area. I called twice and still did not get a call from management. I guess even a storage facility has no liability for items stored on their premises.
Reply from the business

Hi Michael, we apologize that you had this experience and any inconvenience it has caused you. We are looking at vulnerabilities in the fence and enhancing security. We appreciate you bringing this to our attention. Security and customer satisfaction is a top priority for us.

1-star Google reviewRyan F.3 months ago
They make it seem like its $16 a month but then a bunch of fees added on making it $41 to start. Did not say you had to carry insurance. It just says you can pay theirs or get your own. We were not worried about insurance so we declined and it prompts you to pay. We payed then you do all the agreement paperwork that says you have to enter your insurance info before you can move your stuff in. Called customer service and they stated theyd be happy to add insurance to our policy…i bet they would.
Reply from the business

Thank you for your feedback. It sounds like there may have been a misunderstanding during the rental process. Pricing, fees, and insurance requirements are outlined throughout the agreement steps, and coverage is required prior to move-in.

1-star Google reviewTruth P.11 months ago
Hard to get ahold of staff, rarely in office, hard to reach by phone also, was late one day and I got a rude text; "due to your failure to pay on time you have been assessed a $25 late fee, please pay immediately ". Sounds more hostile than professional. I will make sure they dont get another penny. Mice and roaches
Reply from the business

Truth Prevails- We can't seem to find you in the system. Please call us so we can work out these issues at [phone removed]. Thanks!

1-star Google reviewKerry K.Edited 3 years ago
We used Lighthouse to store our camper. The back lot is a literal junkyard! Apparently they don’t care what is stored as long as they get money. When we first arrived, the spot we were assigned had junk on either side that was overflowing into our spot so much you couldn’t even fit a car. The next spot we were assigned we couldn’t maneuver our camper into due to the junk stored opposite not in their spots. Finally got a spot we could use after 3 attempts and being forced to pay more money.
Reply from the business

Kerry- We apologize for your experience. A manager will be reaching out regarding your rented space. We will do what we can to make this right.

1-star Google reviewAudra L.2 years ago
Note: I took a non-climate controlled unit. Memorial Day, 2024: After four months of renting a unit here, #329, I came back today and opened a box of my clothes to find a family of mice (a mom and 4 baby mice) laying ON MY CLOTHES. When I spoke to customer service, I am responsible because I didnt get extra insurance: this place does not properly handle pest control around their outside units. Be advised. The below video is for today.
1-star Google reviewlori D.5 years ago
Back of the buildings are in horrible shape. There are ruts and lots of weeds (looks like a jungle). We couldn’t even see our assigned lot when we were parking our boat. I got poison ivy from the jungle. I can’t believe they feel this is acceptable. I’ve owned my own business before and this would NEVER fly with me. Totally unacceptable for what they are charging. I was told they are doing construction. I guess having pallets of some supplies laying around is “doing construction”.
Reply from the business

We apologize for your inconvenience. The situation has been rectified and we thank you for bringing it to our attention. Please contact us if you have any further questions.

1-star Google reviewGayla10 months ago
DO NOT STORE YOUR ITEMS HERE!!!!! My daughter got this unit for me as I was out of town. Mice will eat your things!!!! They charged me for a unit I was out of long before payment was due,also now telling my daughter that unless she takes pictures of the unit to show that it's empty they will continue to charge her card REALLY 😡. I can't get through to them over a phone call yet when she got the unit the spoke with me OVER THE PHONE. THEY WILL RIP YOU OFF!!!!!
1-star Google reviewAlexandrah S.Edited 2 years ago
Lighthouse Storage is affordable and has plenty of room, but I was bummed to spot mouse droppings in my unit. I've since laid out poison, but it's disappointing to toss stuff. Hopefully they can get pest control services here & that my higher valued furniture won’t be affected by this. Edit: I am Forced to move stuff out of the storage to prevent further damage.
Reply from the business

Alexandrah- Thanks for the feedback. We have regular pest control maintenance at the facility and also perform our own as well. We will look into this matter and get back with you promptly. Thanks.

What satisfied customers point to

The same method, applied to the four and five star reviews. Most movers are praised for the same handful of things, so what is missing here is often as telling as what is present.

  • Professional and courteous36 · 17%
  • Worked hard and fast25 · 12%
  • Kept in touch4 · 2%
  • Turned up when they said1 · <1%

Counted across the 216 four and five star reviews we have read for Lighthouse Storage. A review can mention more than one thing.

In their own words

5-star Google reviewTrixStixwithZacharya year ago
From my very first call with Beth I knew this place was A number 1 for customer service and that the workers are trained to be so polite and nice. My pre expedience, as I am going to be storing my valuables for the next two months, has been exquisite. Ann helped me as I did a walk through of the facility and was so helpful. Janine and Skyler went through all my questions and help set me up as I traverse my storage needs for the next months.
Reply from the business

Hi Zachary, We are elated you had such a great experience with Beth, Ann, Janine, and Skylar! We strive to provide this service for each and every Lighthouse Storage customer. Thank you so much for sharing this positive review with us today, Zachary! Have a wonderful day, The Lighthouse Storage Team

5-star Google reviewDonna K.3 years ago
Approximately four years ago we rented a storage space from Lighthouse. The system of payment is streamlined. Support staff is quick to respond and always helpful and kind. We chose the temperature controlled unit and all my stored items are the same as the day we placed them in storage. Books, fabrics, record albums, Christmas decorations and kitchenware remained in perfect condition. We are totally satisfied with this company.
Reply from the business

Donna- Thank you so much for the great review. We're so glad to hear everything went smoothly for you. Please let us know if we can be of any help in the future! Thank you for choosing Lighthouse Storage!

5-star Google reviewBrian D.6 months ago
Reasonable process, easy to work with! Information was prompt and good!! Happy to be working with them!!
Reply from the business

Thank you so much, Brian! We truly appreciate your kind words and trust. It’s been a pleasure working with you, and we look forward to continuing to support you. If you ever need anything, we’re here to help!

5-star Google reviewJosh K.4 months ago
GREAT EXPERIENCE! Lighthouse Storage customer service is the best! I mistakenly reserved a unit in a nearby town rather than the location I intended and when I arrived with a trailer load of my belongings at 11pm I couldn’t get in the gate because my code wouldn’t work. I called their customer service number, i had to leave a message, it was late so I was worried nobody would be available to help me out, but thank the Lord, Dominic, with Lighthouse Storage called me a couple minutes a later.
Reply from the business

"Thank you for the glowing review, Josh! We know how stressful moving can be, especially at 11 PM, and we are so glad Dominic was there to turn things around for you. Our team takes pride in being available whenever our customers need us, and I’ll be sure to share your 'AAA+' feedback with Dom.

What Google’s own summary highlights

Google surfaces topics it finds across a business’s reviews. They skew positive across every mover we hold, so treat them as a summary of what this company is praised for rather than a balanced picture.

  • new unit37
  • clean units13
  • polite staff13
  • online process9
  • mice6
  • thorough explanations5
  • online rental4
  • affordability3
  • easy booking2
  • gate access2

What the company says about itself

Taken from Lighthouse Storage’s own website. These are statements the business makes, not things we have verified — we have no way to check them, and neither claim nor absence should be read as a finding.

  • Advertises 24/7 availabilitysays on their website
    Show the text this came from

    “…and, when the time comes, retrieve it 24/7 with our drive-up access and gated entr”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.

  • Publishes a licence or operating numbersays on their website
    Show the text this came from

    “Indiana 47586, United States French Lick 9399 West State Road 56, French Lick, Indian”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.

Before you hire Lighthouse Storage

Whatever this company’s numbers say, the same handful of things go wrong on a move. These guides are how to keep your side of it tight.

All moving guides →

Other listings in Evansville

BusinessGoogle rating
Atlas Van Lines, Inc.Mover · Evansville, Indiana4.5757
Furniture Fetchers IncMover · Evansville, Indiana4.7304
NuSpace MovingMover · Evansville, Indiana4.9279
eHandyWaste management service · Evansville, Indiana5.0187
Shetler Moving & Storage, Inc. - Atlas Van LinesMoving and storage service · Evansville, Indiana4.4147
Arctic StorageSelf-storage facility · Evansville, Indiana4.8111

See all 21 listings in Evansville →