Shetler Moving & Storage, Inc. - Atlas Van Lines
Moving and storage service in Evansville, Indiana
Google rating
4.4
Ratings counted
148
Are 1 or 2 star
15.5%Well above typical
The rating breakdown
23 of the 148 ratings in Google’s published star breakdown for Shetler Moving & Storage, Inc. - Atlas Van Lines are one or two star.
Against other listings in Evansville
9.6 percentage points higher than the middle of the 14 listings in Evansville we can publish a rate for.
Google’s published star breakdown
| Rating | Distribution | Count | Share |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 star | 122 | 82.4% | |
| 4 star | 3 | 2.0% | |
| 3 star | 0 | 0% | |
| 2 star | 2 | 1.4% | |
| 1 star | 21 | 14.2% |
Counts as published by Google in its star breakdown, not the reviews we have read. Google also publishes a review count, which does not always match this total. Each row is rounded on its own, so the shares need not add to exactly 100%.
- 0–5%
- 7,048
- 5–10%
- 1,993
- 10–20%
- 1,265
- 20%+
- 454
The marker is Shetler Moving & Storage, Inc. - Atlas Van Lines at 15.5%. The typical mover among the 10,760 we can publish a rate for sits at 3.0%.
Every company with at least 20 ratings in Google’s published star breakdown. Rates come from those breakdowns, not from the reviews we have read.
What the complaints say
Moving goes wrong in a small number of specific ways. These are the ones reviewers describe in the low-star reviews we have read for Shetler Moving & Storage, Inc. - Atlas Van Lines, counted by matching the words they used.
- Damage to belongings10 · 45%
- Crew conduct7 · 32%
- Price rose after the quote3 · 14%
- Items missing or never delivered3 · 14%
- Claim or refund went nowhere2 · 9%
- Stopped responding1 · 5%
Counted across the 22 one and two star reviews we have read for Shetler Moving & Storage, Inc. - Atlas Van Lines. A review can describe more than one problem, so these do not add to 100%. Each share is rounded on its own.
In their own words
Initial survey started out well. Tom Shetler did the survey himself. The day of the move.....not a good experience. Moving crew was horrible. Did not use the carpet protector, so we had to have the carpets cleaned again afterwards. Crew did not pay attention to what was being loaded on top of what. "Top Load Only" boxes had boxes of books and other heavy items on top. They seemed to be more interested in how quickly they could get the job done, not how well they could get the job done.
Unbelievably bad experience. Lost 14 (that’s right 14!) boxes of my possessions! Crew on the receiving end weren’t professional movers—they were vagrants hired on the cheap. One had a herniated disc and laid on the floor moaning every 5 minutes. One asked me if I had any meds to help with some pain he was having! I called the company bright and early the next morning and complained. Called and emailed multiple times. Their response was: the paperwork (that THEY filled out) didn’t support the missing items.
The moving crew was pretty good, but the guy who did the estimate was very wrong. He came and did an estimate for my apartment. He said 3 guys could pack and move everything in 2 days. I doubted this and called to see if they could come out and do another estimate. They said they trusted their guys. When the moving crew arrived they told me they would need extra guys and more time. All of this would cost extra money, above and beyond what I had budgeted.
Hi Brooke, Thank you for your feedback—we're grateful for the opportunity to assist with your move and sincerely apologize that it didn't meet our high standards as a top moving company in Evansville, Indiana, offering reliable local and long-distance services.
WARNING!!!! WARNING!!! WARNING!!! We hire Shelter moving to relocate our most valued household items. From day one of the movers arriving we had issues. Movers complaining about the job being under bid and not having enough room on the truck to fit all of our things. A second truck had to be called in to accommodate the rest of our furniture including baby beds that needed to be at our new location for our children to sleep in.
Leaving a review in this manner is quite out of character, but necessary for future customers of Shetler Moving. Upon the moving crews arrival, I was informed that the way in which I packed the boxes was incorrect. Although this was frustrating, as no instructions were provided, I persisted in being helpful and listening to the crew leader in my home. That said, shortly after the box complaint, an overarching issue appeared.
Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback about your recent interstate move with Shetler Moving & Storage. We truly appreciate every review as it helps us continue serving the Evansville, IN and tri-state area with the highest standards of care for local, long-distance, and interstate…
With a rather last minute out-of-state move coming up, I reached out to two local moving companies to get quotes as well as see if they had availability on my preferred move date. I first contacted Shetler moving and waited several days for a response, only to be told no one could come give me an estimate for a week or so. The communication was lacking throughout the whole process.
Albuquerque branch WORST moving experience. Found out the company is going out of business in this town and I think they did things out of spite with our move. They broke many many things that are of sentimental value as well as other things. They also packed with no sense whatsoever. EVERY box was mis-marked with contents AND room! Rooms where mixed within same boxes.. Heavy stuff packed WITH Fragile light stuff..
1. We were loyal customers of Shetler Moving & Storage- we have moved 3 times in the last 8 years. We used them every time. 2. We used to live next door to the owner & adored he & his wife. 3. Family friends with the estimator - who truly was sorry for our experience 4. I am a real estate agent & refer Shetler on a regular basis. 5. We have never taken out extra insurance. Our experience has been good & it never warranted it. We were told the crew they had now was the best they have had in years.
What satisfied customers point to
The same method, applied to the four and five star reviews. Most movers are praised for the same handful of things, so what is missing here is often as telling as what is present.
- Professional and courteous54 · 53%
- Worked hard and fast36 · 35%
- Turned up when they said17 · 17%
- Careful with belongings14 · 14%
- Kept in touch4 · 4%
- Price matched the quote1 · <1%
Counted across the 102 four and five star reviews we have read for Shetler Moving & Storage, Inc. - Atlas Van Lines. A review can mention more than one thing.
In their own words
Made my cross country move extremely simple and easy. Mallorie was fantastic, and there was no muss or fuss. The team that moved me took excellent care of my things, not a single item lost or damaged. They assembled everything, went through a high value checklist quickly and efficiently. I was constantly communicated to and every time I reached out, I received a detailed response within 15 - 20 minutes.
We are thrilled to hear about your positive experience with our team! It's wonderful that Mallorie and the moving crew made your cross-country move smooth and stress-free. We pride ourselves on our communication and care for our clients' belongings, and we’re glad to see those efforts reflected in…
I would like to start this review by stating that I feel like I am a demanding client. That being said, I was tasked with a short notice long distance move due to work. I called several moving companies and Shetler was the only one who responded and showed up to give an estimate. I worked with Becky throughout the entire process and she is FABULOUS!!!! The owner Mr. Shetler came to estimate my move. He was very professional and his quote was within $800 of the final cost. Mind you, it is ONLY an estimate.
I don't want to gush because the review might read insincere or paid for, but I highly recommend this business. The three young men they sent, Brian, Isaac, and Juan, were professional, polite, and helpful. Brian took the lead brilliantly especially for someone so young, but was polite to his helpers. It was amazing how they were able to lift and maneuver some very large pieces through tight spots. They knew how to dismantle and reassemble furniture adeptly. They worked diligently through an 8.5 hour day.
Thank you so much for your kind words and recommendation! We are thrilled to hear that you had an excellent experience with our team, and we greatly appreciate your recognition of Brian, Isaac, Juan, and Becky for their professionalism and dedication.
What an absolutely fantastic experience! From the estimator who arrived on time to the young men that carried out our move, everything was nearly flawless! (Only issue was the slight rain!) Dakota, Andrew, and Jacob were highly competent, professional, polite, and a joy to work with during our two day move! We also had Bailey and Isaac who were with us one day each and were equally qualified and eager to help!
Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We're thrilled to hear that everything went smoothly with your move despite the slight rain. We're proud to have such a dedicated and professional team, like Dakota, Andrew, Jacob, Bailey, and Isaac, who helped make your moving experience enjoyable.
What Google’s own summary highlights
Google surfaces topics it finds across a business’s reviews. They skew positive across every mover we hold, so treat them as a summary of what this company is praised for rather than a balanced picture.
- cost14
- polite staff8
- hard working staff8
- careful with belongings6
- efficient staff6
- professional movers6
- moving crew4
- no damage3
- easy process2
- timely staff2
What the company says about itself
Taken from Shetler Moving & Storage, Inc. - Atlas Van Lines’s own website. These are statements the business makes, not things we have verified — we have no way to check them, and neither claim nor absence should be read as a finding.
- Says it is licensedsays on their website
Show the text this came from
“Moving & Storage is proud to be a licensed agent of Atlas Van Lines. Atlas Van Lin”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.
- Describes itself as family ownedsays on their website
Show the text this came from
“With over 125 years of experience as a family-owned business and an agent for Atlas Van Lin”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.
- Advertises 24/7 availabilitysays on their website
Show the text this came from
“…vaulted options for valuables with 24/7 surveillance. Our movers Louisville KY”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.
- Advertises free estimatessays on their website
Show the text this came from
“…quality local moving company. Get Free Quote Household Moves Corporate Moves Commerc”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.
- States how long it has tradedsays on their website
Show the text this came from
“…and businesses in the region. With over 125 years of experience as a family-owned busines”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.
Where else this company appears
Pages elsewhere that name this business. Matched on name and location, so a listing here is a lead worth checking rather than a confirmed identity.
- merchantcircle.comdirectory
- mapquest.comdirectory
- yellowpages.comdirectory