Skip to content

Molloy Moving & Storage

Mover in Islip, New York

Its address is in Farmingdale, New York. It appears here because Google returns it for Islip.

Google rating

4.7

Ratings counted

500

Are 1 or 2 star

5.8%Around typical

The rating breakdown

29 of the 500 ratings in Google’s published star breakdown for Molloy Moving & Storage are one or two star.

Against other movers in Islip

This company5.8%
Typical mover in Islip1.8%

4.0 percentage points higher than the middle of the 15 movers in Islip we can publish a rate for.

Google’s published star breakdown

Distribution of star ratings as published by Google
RatingDistributionCountShare
5 star
44789.4%
4 star
214.2%
3 star
30.6%
2 star
71.4%
1 star
224.4%

Counts as published by Google in its star breakdown, not the reviews we have read. Google also publishes a review count, which does not always match this total. Each row is rounded on its own, so the shares need not add to exactly 100%.

Against every mover we can rate
0–5%
7,614
5–10%
2,324
10–20%
1,521
20%+
538

The marker is Molloy Moving & Storage at 5.8%. The typical mover among the 11,997 we can publish a rate for sits at 3.2%.

Every company with at least 20 ratings in Google’s published star breakdown. Rates come from those breakdowns, not from the reviews we have read.

What the complaints say

Moving goes wrong in a small number of specific ways. These are the ones reviewers describe in the low-star reviews we have read for Molloy Moving & Storage, counted by matching the words they used.

  • Damage to belongings12 · 46%
  • Late, delayed or a no-show5 · 19%
  • Items missing or never delivered3 · 12%
  • Crew conduct3 · 12%
  • Price rose after the quote2 · 8%
  • Claim or refund went nowhere2 · 8%
  • Stopped responding1 · 4%

Counted across the 26 one and two star reviews we have read for Molloy Moving & Storage. A review can describe more than one problem, so these do not add to 100%. Each share is rounded on its own.

In their own words

1-star Google reviewrosie R.Edited 4 months ago
Horrible experience!! Items stolen, boxes opened and things taken out, no communication about delay, driver and wife threatened me and then called their dispatcher that they did not feel safe when unloading the truck! The packers marked items as "packed by owner" when they packed them. My kitchen table is warped and irrepairable and they denied the claim. My Kitchen Aid mixer was packed by them, they wrote I packed it, it is damaged - denied.
Reply from the business

We regret to hear about the challenges you faced during your move. Your experience is not reflective of the standards we strive to uphold. Since we did not haul this shipment for you, it is best to reach out to Mayflower Customer Care at [phone removed] and continue to work with them.

1-star Google reviewJanet Z.10 years ago
A tale of damages, lies, and lost items. Molloy Bros was perfectly accommodating BEFORE I committed to anything--in fact, the positive Google + reviews led me to believe they were reliable. However, my experience was HELL. 1) My movers were running 6 hours late to come get my stuff. Kim Davis, the coordinator, had no idea and would not return my phone calls. 2) Despite paying for additional wrapping for my furniture, this was not completed, which led to many items arriving damaged.
1-star Google reviewAmirah O.Edited 3 years ago
Don’t use this company, they will make fraudulent charges on your credit card. TLDR: They charged an extra $1200 to my credit card with no warning or explanation, refusing to provide an itemized list of charges. ****** Update ***** Definitely fraud. I finally received an invoice after writing this review. The company added an extra 7 hours of moving time, plus an extra person for the delivery. The move was 7.5 hours for move out and move in, but they charged me for 14.5 hours @ $236 per hour.
Reply from the business

Hello so sorry that you had this experience. Molloy Bros follows all rules and regulations mandated by the state. We will be reviewing your case right away to give you full documentation on the status of your invoice. Your move probably went over in either time or materials which.

1-star Google reviewGayle J.Edited 7 months ago
Disappointed with the crew that came to collect my items. The manager of the team (Juan) was unfriendly and defensive. The other two did not seem to have much training, nor care. I should not have to advise people not to place boxes on my uncovered furniture, nor instruct them to place blankets over metal furniture stands to prevent damage. Upon arrival of my goods in Chicago, I learned that my credenza (expensive piece) had not been prepped properly- doors had not been secured and folded to the back of the item.
Reply from the business

Doing business with integrity is important to us and customers are our top priority. Our Customer Service Director will be reaching out to you to further discuss your concerns.

1-star Google reviewSuzanne G.3 years ago
The short version of this story is that after a month of trying to have our belongings delivered, we still do not have them. We are paying rent and utilities on a home we cannot live in. Read on for more information. From the beginning, our move was bungled every step of the way. While I assure you that everyone I interacted with was pleasant, nothing went right. No one communicated with me. It's been 1 month since my initial contact to have my belongings delivered to my new home, and I am still waiting.
Reply from the business

Suzanne, we're sorry to hear you were dissatisfied with our services. Quality customer service and doing business with honesty and integrity are extremely important to us. We understand our team contacted you via phone with updates on your delivery and again today.

1-star Google reviewAndy W.8 months ago
We had an extremely disappointing experience with Mayflower/Molloy and would strongly advise others to look elsewhere for moving services. We hired this company for a long-distance move from New York to South Carolina, and what should have been a smooth process turned into a stressful ordeal. The New York crew was unprofessional and careless with our belongings. Our furniture and boxes were handled roughly, and our walls and ceilings were damaged during the move-out process.
Reply from the business

We're sorry to hear you were dissatisfied with our services. Quality customer service and doing business with honesty and integrity are extremely important to us. We understand you have a pending claim, please contact Mayflower Claims at [phone removed] to discuss filing your claim or visit…

1-star Google reviewRae F.2 years ago
DO NOT USE THIS COMPANY! They are frauds. Molloy Bros is an affiliate of Mayflower Moving Company. They moved us from New York City to Texas in October 2023. We purchased extra insurance for Full (Replacement) Value Protection. Their high value form was too short for all our high value items to be listed. Consequently, I listed each on an Excel spreadsheet, which I emailed to our Move Coordinator and our Move Consultant. Both assured me that we were fully covered.
Reply from the business

We understand you spoke to Mayflower Claims about the specifics of your claim, and they would be happy to clarify or answer any further questions you have about the settlement. Please feel free to contact your claims representative about the Arbitration program offered by the ATA.

1-star Google reviewPH7 years ago
We had, and have, a terrible experience. Beside, the original person that gave us an estimate, which was a very precise gentleman, we happen to think, everything else was, and is a total disaster. I do not suggest anybody to use this location of Molloy Bros, although nobody contacted us after the initial bad survey we gave to the headquarter. Maybe in an other locations they are professionals, this one disrupted our life, totally. Terrible experience nobody should go through this, and pay thousands of dollars.
Reply from the business

Betty, we’re very sorry to hear about this and would like to investigate this. However, we are unable to identify you based on your review. At your convenience, please call Customer Care at [phone removed]. Thank you.

What satisfied customers point to

The same method, applied to the four and five star reviews. Most movers are praised for the same handful of things, so what is missing here is often as telling as what is present.

  • Professional and courteous220 · 52%
  • Worked hard and fast140 · 33%
  • Careful with belongings112 · 26%
  • Turned up when they said74 · 17%
  • Kept in touch33 · 8%
  • Price matched the quote4 · <1%

Counted across the 427 four and five star reviews we have read for Molloy Moving & Storage. A review can mention more than one thing.

In their own words

5-star Google reviewFrank F.6 years ago
It was a pleasure working with Molloy Brothers Moving & Storage. From my initial phone call of inquiry, to the estimator who came out to my location, pricing and finally the moving crew and the move itself was flawless. I was particularly impressed with the back office and the movers themselves with their concern for my comfort and their concern for my possessions. they were extremely attentive to care of my belongings. The arrived on time and quickly went work wrapping and moving the furniture.
Reply from the business

Frank. Thank you so much! What great feedback! We are so pleased to hear we were able to accommodate your needs and that you found our crew to be pleasant and helpful. We'll make sure to share your comments with the entire team. We appreciate the fantastic review and your recommendation.

5-star Google reviewCaroline G.6 years ago
Moving coast to coast is a daunting thing but thought I made a good decision to go with May Flowers (Molloy Bros). I talked to 20+ moving companies and ended up using them even though their price point was higher. Overall thought the service was worth the extra money - no damage (my computer monitor cracked but think it’s because I didn’t pack it very well), accurate delivery window (which was very important for me), fast service, nice staff on both sides, no hidden cost (very important!!
Reply from the business

Caroline, Thank you so much for taking the time to share your positive experience. We strive to provide this level of service to all our customers, and we are so pleased to hear we met this goal during your relocation with us.

5-star Google reviewMary H.6 years ago
This was our 4th move in 15 years & for all, we had Molloy Bros. move us. George came each time & quickly assessed our needs & gave an accurate quote, I always liked that he gave great suggestions to help with the moves. Each time the customer service from the office was outstanding & this time Hope was amazing, she is so calm & willing to assist in any way even to the point of calling after her work hours were completed. As for the actual move I can't say enough. Juan & his crew of Marcello & Tito were fantastic.
Reply from the business

Thank you so much for you review!

5-star Google reviewDee N.Edited 7 years ago
Our Sunday, May 19, 2019 our furniture showed up on time. Jack, Fredrick, Terrance and Chez did a fantastic job. They really worked very hard getting all of our furniture into the house and set up. We had approximately 200 boxes that they had to bring into the house and were careful to put them in the appropriate room which included 8 rooms. They were all very courteous and respectful and easy to deal with.
Reply from the business

We’re happy to hear you had a great move, Dee. Thanks for sharing your feedback. We’ll be sure to share your comments with everyone involved. Best of luck in your new home and thank you for the recommendation!

What Google’s own summary highlights

Google surfaces topics it finds across a business’s reviews. They skew positive across every mover we hold, so treat them as a summary of what this company is praised for rather than a balanced picture.

  • job by juan and his crew78
  • estimate51
  • storage facility14
  • courteous staff13
  • moving crew10
  • courteous and polite8
  • efficient crew7
  • quick move6
  • accurate quote3
  • punctual movers2

What the company says about itself

Taken from Molloy Moving & Storage’s own website. These are statements the business makes, not things we have verified — we have no way to check them, and neither claim nor absence should be read as a finding.

  • States a founding yearsays on their website
    Show the text this came from

    “New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut since 1945, Molloy is the reliable choice for all”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.

  • States how long it has tradedsays on their website
    Show the text this came from

    “…trusted choice with a proud history of more than 70 years in the business. We have successfully r”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.

  • Advertises free estimatessays on their website
    Show the text this came from

    “…and cherished memories. Get Your Free Estimate Please use our contact form for any inq”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.

  • Advertises 24/7 availabilitysays on their website
    Show the text this came from

    “Island, Queens, and New Jersey offer 24/7 security and temperature control. Benef”Raw text captured from the page, including any surrounding navigation.

Where else this company appears

Pages elsewhere that name this business. Matched on name and location, so a listing here is a lead worth checking rather than a confirmed identity.

  • yelp.comreviews
  • instagram.comsocial
  • facebook.comsocial
  • bbb.orgreviews
  • consumeraffairs.comreviews

Before you hire Molloy Moving & Storage

Whatever this company’s numbers say, the same handful of things go wrong on a move. These guides are how to keep your side of it tight.

All moving guides →

Other movers in Islip

BusinessGoogle rating
Verity Van Lines IncMoving and storage service · Islip, New York · based in Seaford4.91,195
Liberty Moving & Storage, Agent for United VanlinesMover · Islip, New York · based in Commack4.7666
Maffucci MovingMoving and storage service · Islip, New York · based in Amityville4.5390
All Terrain Moving and Junk RemovalMover · Islip, New York · based in Islandia5.0264
Relocators - Moving & StorageMover · Islip, New York · based in Hauppauge4.8233
NGM Moving & Junk removalMoving and storage service · Islip, New York5.0211

See all 15 movers in Islip →